Sunday 7 February 2016

Sheikh Al Junaydi

One of the most overlooked characters throughout The Thief And The Dogs has been Sheikh Al Junaydi. Sheikh is the person who Said immediately goes to for spiritual purposes and he represents the complete opposite of what Said is. Sheikh's characteristics represent optimism and positive, if there is anyone who Said should be like or should try to emulate, he should look no further to the Sheikh as he represents the clean mindset and the harmless creature that Said Mahran should be like. Mahfouz integrates Sheikh in his novel in order to showcase a nice contrast between his personality and Said's personality with the Sheikh portraying the morally correct mindset one should have as he doesn't believe in taking revenge and striking back at others. As readers, we consistently see Said's action as being morally incorrect and envisioning Said as a person who really needs a mental intervention therefore with the way Sheikh is characterizes it adds a nice dimension to show living proof of what Said Mahran should be like. Sheikh offers Said food to eat and a roof to love under, he consistently aims to resuscitate Said and give Said a better understanding of what he has done than what Said even realizes himself. Sheikh is consistently looked upon highly throughout the story and is always looked at by Mahfouz as a possible “higher power” and Said’s superior as he is consistently a problem solver and one who always makes sure to help those around him. Sheikh is a rather flat character as there aren’t so many points in the story involving him nor is there any mentions of him having a darker side but the flat levels that Mahfouz uses to portray him are really able to showcase the good side of people throughout this story while provide another perspective on the behavior of a person with decent morals at the time of the Egyptian revolution.

The positive characterization of Sheikh really helps make the negative and greedy behavior of Said Mahran stand out. Said is desperately wanting to seek revenge and condemn the people who have done him wrong in the past and through showing the differences in the beliefs and ideologies of Said Mahran and Sheikh, Mahfouz really brings out the morally incorrect behavior of Said and lets the readers really dig into the wrong things that Said is focusing on. Said is continued to be characterized as vengeful and blinded into his own pride as he strongly believes what he is doing is correct and through using a very positive and intelligent character like Sheikh by integrating him in moments where he consistently helps out Said Mahran. Mahfouz enlarges the effect of what Said is doing even more and further helps the readers realize that he isn’t going to get anywhere with his attitude and will only get somewhere in life with a positive attitude like Sheikh’s. Sheikh’s positive attitude indirectly sheds more light on the negative characteristics of Said Mahran. Overall, the work of Mahfouz through contrasting 2 different people help in illustrate the theme of revenge throughout the story. Sheikh is highly against revenge and we see throughout the book that he persistently reminds Said about not taking revenge and moving on with life. Said however with his ignorant ego completely cuts off Said’s words and he decides to continue to try to take revenge which in the end leads to his ultimate downfall as he dies at the end of the story. Mahfouz tackles the revenge theme to portray Said as a tragic hero and uses Sheikh as a key piece in the novel to showcase the peaks and troughs of the story while help show the journey of Said Mahran from his release from jail to his death.  Sheikh helps assist Said’s ignorance which is one of the main reasons why he dies in the end.

Wednesday 3 February 2016

Thesis Statement

Mahfouz uses the stream of consciousness technique through the main character Said in order to create an open ended ideology on various values and themes, primarily betrayal

Monday 1 February 2016

Said as a tragic hero

Said's hamartia/flaw is being unable to let go of the past. He holds grudges towards people which is proven through his hatred for Illish. Said is out there for revenge and his inability to let go of the bad things that have happened in his past are what make him a flawed character. His belief in getting back at people is what drives his character's journey throughout the story and eventually proves to doom him as he dies at the end.

Said has excessive pride through being overconfident in his beliefs of getting back at Illish and through his hatred for Illish and Nabawiyya. Said is very stuck up with what he is doing and he believes what he is doing is morally correct even though ideally he should be focusing on a new life rather than bursting back into his past for revenge. His excessive pride takes a big toll on him as he dies in the end primarily due to his ignorance of finding the solution to the problem he was having.

The biggest turning point in the story is when Said sees his daughter Sana but only to be rejected by her with Sana disapproving of what Said is doing. Said had waited for a long time to see Sana with her meaning almost everything to him but the rejection further stimulates Said's desire to strike back at Illish, which turns out to be the wrong thing to do. Losing Sana meant that Said truly lost a huge part of himself. His realizations do occur when he tries to murder Illish. He starts to realize the new identity and the bad things he has done when trying to murder Illish which cause Said to realize how far he has fallen in his life.

His decline was deserved and his demise was definitely bound to happen due to his ignorance. He knew that murder attempts can definitely go wrong and put him in more trouble in his life. He understood the consequences of his vengeful personality but he stuck to those negative characteristics which resulted in a death that was brought upon himself.